- Eyewitness Evidence
- Documentary Evidence
- Corroborating Evidence
- Scientific Evidence
- Rebuttal Evidence
- Identity Evidence
- Psychological Evidence
- Profile Evidence
- Fingerprint Evidence
- Medical Evidence
- Circumstantial Evidence
Throughout his investigation, Lee remained a skeptical atheist. It was not until afterwards that he sat down as an unbiased juror and came to a conclusion beyond reasonable--not conceivable--doubt. He found that he had more evidence in support of Jesus' life, death, and resurrection, and for his deity than some in court had, but were sent to death row! In other words, the evidence is very powerful, being both sound and valid, able to stand up to questions, tests, and cross-examinations, so powerful that it lead Strobel to become a Christian. As a result, Strobel's entire life changed for the better, so much so that his own daughter told her mother that she wanted God to do the same thing to her that he did to her dad (p. 269). Thus, one more piece of evidence comes to play: experiential evidence. Strobel's life stood in the foreground as proof of the work of Jesus, which confirmed the facts of the aforementioned objective evidences. Let's briefly take a look at these.
Eyewitness Evidence (p. 259)
- The gospels are superb witnesses and are to be considered reliable and trustworthy.
- The gospels are not the product of spiritual propaganda and legend.
- The gospels stand up to scrutiny, passing the eight evidential tests for determining the validity of eyewitness evidence with flying colors.
Documentary Evidence (p. 260)
- The New Testament is unparalleled in its being preserved throughout time.
- The New Testament today is 99.5% free of textual discrepancies, and none of the discrepancies that exist bring any major Christian doctrine into doubt.
- The New Testament that we have today is very much the same documents that were written in the first century.
Corroborating Evidence (p. 260)
- There is a good deal of credible evidence for Jesus outside of the gospels.
- Outside biblical sources we find mention of Jesus as a worker of miracles and as the Christ who was crucified, and even though he died a most grotesque death, his disciples, believing that he was still alive, worshiped him as God.
- One scholar was able to document "thirty-nine ancient sources that corroborate more than one hundred facts concerning Jesus' life, teachings, crucifixion, and resurrection."
Scientific Evidence (pp. 260-61)
- Archaeology confirms the New Testament's credibility rather than debunk it.
- No archaeological discovery has ever disproved a biblical reference.
Rebuttal Evidence (p. 261)
- The Jesus Seminar studies Jesus with huge presuppositions, such as the impossibility of miracles, it utilized questionable criteria for its methodological approach to studying the gospels, and some of the members of the Seminar have tried to sell mythologized "documents of extremely dubious quality."
- We can confidently claim that "the Jesus of faith is the same as the Jesus of history."
Identity Evidence (p. 261)
- Jesus did believe and know that he was the Son of God.
- Jesus did believe and know that he was the Son of Man.
- Jesus did believe and know that he was the Christ, the Messiah.
- Jesus did believe and know that he was the only Savior of the world.
Psychological Evidence (pp. 261-62)
- Jesus was not crazy or mentally ill.
- Jesus backed up his claim to deity by performing miracles, demonstrating power over nature, unparalleled teaching, and also "with his own resurrection, which was the final authentication of his identity."
Profile Evidence (p. 262)
- Jesus fulfilled the attributes of God: omniscience; omnipresence; omnipotence; eternality; and immutability.
- The New Testament is clear "that Jesus ultimately possessed every qualification of deity."
Fingerprint Evidence (p. 262)
- The odds of Jesus fulfilling the Old Testament prophecies were one in a trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion.
- Jesus is the only one who fulfilled the prophecies written several centuries before he was born.
Medical Evidence (pp. 262-63)
- Jesus did not survive the crucifixion, and he died on the cross.
- Jesus did not faint and merely wake up earlier while in the tomb.
- Roman executioners were extremely efficient killers, because they would face death if their victims ever came off the cross alive, so it is highly improbable for Jesus to come down the cross alive.
Circumstantial Evidence (p. 263-64)
- Jesus' "disciples were in a unique position to know whether the Resurrection happened, and they went to their deaths proclaiming it was true. Nobody knowingly and willingly dies for a lie."
- Aside from the Resurrection, "there's no good reason why skeptics like Paul and James would have been converted and would have died for their faith."
- After a matter of weeks after the Crucifixion, "thousands of Jews began abandoning key social practices that had critical sociological and religious importance for centuries. They believed they risked damnation if they were wrong."
- Both Communion and baptism affirm Jesus' resurrection and deity.
- The emergence of the Church in the face of brutal Roman opposition and persecution demands an explanation that only the Resurrection can provide.
Now that we have looked at the basic facts of the evidence, let's look at their implications.
Strobel wrote the following on pages 266 and 67:
- If Jesus is the Son of God, his teachings are more than just good ideas from a wise teacher; they are divine insights on which I can confidently build my life.
- If Jesus sets the standard for morality, I can now have an unwavering foundation for my choices and decisions, rather than basing them on the ever-shifting sands of expediency and self-centeredness.
- If Jesus did rise from the dead, he's still alive today and available for me to encounter on a personal basis.
- If Jesus conquered death, he can open the door of eternal life for me, too.
- If Jesus has divine power, he has the supernatural ability to guide me and help me and transform me as I follow him.
- If Jesus personally knows the pain of loss and suffering, he can comfort and encourage me in the midst of the turbulence that he himself warned is inevitable in a world corrupted by sin.
- If Jesus loves me as he says, he has my best interests at heart. That means I have nothing to lose and everything to gain by committing myself to him and his purposes.
- If Jesus is who he claims to be (and remember, no leader of any other major religion has even pretended to be God), as my Creator he rightfully deserves my allegiance, obedience, and worship.
To that I must say, "Amen."
Strobel, Lee. 1998. The Case for Christ: a journalist's personal investigation of the evidence for Jesus. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
Strobel, Lee. 1998. The Case for Christ: a journalist's personal investigation of the evidence for Jesus. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
